Wikipedia talk:Articles for deletion/True.Origin Archive

Claims on the AfD

edit
  • "This is the only creationary website that talk.origins bothers to respond to. It has many links to replies and rebuttals on True.origins." This is I believe an exaggeration. The talkorigins site makes explicit mention of True.Origins on only four pages: the Feedback page and these three: [1][2][3] (it probably has links on more, but this gives you some idea). HrafnTalkStalk 03:41, 17 January 2009 (UTC)Reply
  • "major website , perhaps, as mentioned just above, the major one of its sort." The most-major-creationist-website-that-is-devoted-to-tracking-TalkOrigins is not indicative of a "major website" (biggest fish in a very small pond). Would a liberal website devoted to tracking/rebutting the Drudge Report be a "major"/notable website worthy of an article? I doubt it. At best it could hope for an EL on the Drudge article. HrafnTalkStalk 03:41, 17 January 2009 (UTC)Reply